CycleBanter.com

CycleBanter.com (http://www.cyclebanter.com/index.php)
-   Techniques (http://www.cyclebanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Cassette change? (http://www.cyclebanter.com/showthread.php?t=259826)

Mark Cleary[_3_] July 9th 20 06:23 PM

Cassette change?
 
I am easy on drive-train's. I get 6000 miles on chains without going over the limit on 11 speed shimano. My question is right now my cassette a 11-28 has some 16000 miles on it and works fine. No Skipping I am getting ready to put a new chain on pretty soon maybe another 1000 miles. Should I go ahead and swap out the cassette. My instincts tell me to just keep riding. If for some reason a new chain causes a skip then yes i need new cassette. The bike is Ultegra 6800 and shifts like a dream. I put a new cable on the rear today and was thinking maybe just order up a not only the chain but a new cassette. Cassette are a mystery on wear for sure.

What do all the minds in here think? It is not broke leave alone or just go new and be done for hopefully anther 16000 miles, not kilometres.

Deacon Mark

Mark J. July 9th 20 06:58 PM

Cassette change?
 
On 7/9/2020 10:23 AM, Mark Cleary wrote:
I am easy on drive-train's. I get 6000 miles on chains without going over the limit on 11 speed shimano. My question is right now my cassette a 11-28 has some 16000 miles on it and works fine. No Skipping I am getting ready to put a new chain on pretty soon maybe another 1000 miles. Should I go ahead and swap out the cassette. My instincts tell me to just keep riding. If for some reason a new chain causes a skip then yes i need new cassette. The bike is Ultegra 6800 and shifts like a dream. I put a new cable on the rear today and was thinking maybe just order up a not only the chain but a new cassette. Cassette are a mystery on wear for sure.

What do all the minds in here think? It is not broke leave alone or just go new and be done for hopefully anther 16000 miles, not kilometres.

Deacon Mark

Change the chain before it shows symptoms. Change the cassette after it
shows symptoms (i.e. chain skipping).

Does anyone here know a downside to running a worn cassette BESIDES
chain skipping?

Mark J.

Frank Krygowski[_4_] July 9th 20 07:47 PM

Cassette change?
 
On 7/9/2020 1:58 PM, Mark J. wrote:
On 7/9/2020 10:23 AM, Mark Cleary wrote:
I am easy on drive-train's. I get 6000 miles on chains without going
over the limit on 11 speed shimano. My question is right now my
cassette a 11-28 has some 16000 miles on it and works fine. No
Skipping I am getting ready to put a new chain on pretty soon maybe
another 1000 miles. Should I go ahead and swap out the cassette. My
instincts tell me to just keep riding. If for some reason a new chain
causes a skip then yes i need new cassette. The bike is Ultegra 6800
and shifts like a dream. I put a new cable on the rear today and was
thinking maybe just order up a not only the chain but a new cassette.
Cassette are a mystery on wear for sure.

What do all the minds in here think? It is not broke leave alone or
just go new and be done for hopefully anther 16000 miles, not kilometres.

Deacon Mark

Change the chain before it shows symptoms.Â* Change the cassette after it
shows symptoms (i.e. chain skipping).


I'd say try the old cassette, but be ready to change it. I strongly
suspect the chain will skip. Please report back.

Does anyone here know a downside to running a worn cassette BESIDES
chain skipping?


I don't have any data, but I'd bet that the chain will wear much more
quickly. I think the load will be more concentrated on one link at a
time, instead of shared between several chain links.


--
- Frank Krygowski

Tosspot[_3_] July 9th 20 08:10 PM

Cassette change?
 
On 09/07/2020 19:23, Mark Cleary wrote:
I am easy on drive-train's. I get 6000 miles on chains without going
over the limit on 11 speed shimano. My question is right now my
cassette a 11-28 has some 16000 miles on it and works fine. No
Skipping I am getting ready to put a new chain on pretty soon maybe
another 1000 miles. Should I go ahead and swap out the cassette. My
instincts tell me to just keep riding. If for some reason a new chain
causes a skip then yes i need new cassette. The bike is Ultegra 6800
and shifts like a dream. I put a new cable on the rear today and was
thinking maybe just order up a not only the chain but a new cassette.
Cassette are a mystery on wear for sure.

What do all the minds in here think? It is not broke leave alone or
just go new and be done for hopefully anther 16000 miles, not
kilometres.


Good question. Damn good question.

I would say it's already too late and ride it out and then change
everything. I'd have changed the chain at 2,000 miles, but that ain't
the question :-)

Mark Cleary[_3_] July 9th 20 08:20 PM

Cassette change?
 
For me I really don’t think it will skip on a new chain. I live in flatlands Illinois and keep my chain clean. I have quick link and will remove and dunk at 500-750 mile intervals. I am not a masher. I guess I may go ahead order a new chain and cassette.

Deacon Mark

Mark J. July 9th 20 09:50 PM

Cassette change?
 
On 7/9/2020 12:20 PM, Mark Cleary wrote:
For me I really don’t think it will skip on a new chain. I live in flatlands Illinois and keep my chain clean. I have quick link and will remove and dunk at 500-750 mile intervals. I am not a masher. I guess I may go ahead order a new chain and cassette.

Deacon Mark


You seem to put on enough miles, having a cassette in reserve seems
reasonable. What brand of chain? I'm told some last a LOT longer than
others.

I *may* have got 6k on a Campy chain once, a chain I cleaned
obsessively, but I really don't remember the number. I've changed to
frequently-changed KMC's now.

Mark J.

Mark Cleary[_3_] July 9th 20 09:57 PM

Cassette change?
 
I have all Shimano drive train. I buy the 701 directional chains and either Ultegra or 105 cassettes. I think all Shimano shifts better. I have all 6800 equipped bike. I personally believe all Shimano gets best most precise shifting. Mine shifts perfect never misses until cable wears out. Then it is always cable head gets frayed.

Deacon Mark.

AMuzi July 9th 20 10:38 PM

Cassette change?
 
On 7/9/2020 12:58 PM, Mark J. wrote:
On 7/9/2020 10:23 AM, Mark Cleary wrote:
I am easy on drive-train's. I get 6000 miles on chains
without going over the limit on 11 speed shimano. My
question is right now my cassette a 11-28 has some 16000
miles on it and works fine. No Skipping I am getting ready
to put a new chain on pretty soon maybe another 1000
miles. Should I go ahead and swap out the cassette. My
instincts tell me to just keep riding. If for some reason
a new chain causes a skip then yes i need new cassette.
The bike is Ultegra 6800 and shifts like a dream. I put a
new cable on the rear today and was thinking maybe just
order up a not only the chain but a new cassette. Cassette
are a mystery on wear for sure.

What do all the minds in here think? It is not broke leave
alone or just go new and be done for hopefully anther
16000 miles, not kilometres.

Deacon Mark

Change the chain before it shows symptoms. Change the
cassette after it shows symptoms (i.e. chain skipping).

Does anyone here know a downside to running a worn cassette
BESIDES chain skipping?

Mark J.


Yes, riding out of the saddle. Could be very much 'down'.

Since there's no definitive way to know about sprocket wear,
change your chain and don't stand up for the test ride
afterwards.

--
Andrew Muzi
www.yellowjersey.org/
Open every day since 1 April, 1971



John B.[_3_] July 9th 20 11:59 PM

Cassette change?
 
On Thu, 9 Jul 2020 10:23:22 -0700 (PDT), Mark Cleary
wrote:

I am easy on drive-train's. I get 6000 miles on chains without going over the limit on 11 speed shimano. My question is right now my cassette a 11-28 has some 16000 miles on it and works fine. No Skipping I am getting ready to put a new chain on pretty soon maybe another 1000 miles. Should I go ahead and swap out the cassette. My instincts tell me to just keep riding. If for some reason a new chain causes a skip then yes i need new cassette. The bike is Ultegra 6800 and shifts like a dream. I put a new cable on the rear today and was thinking maybe just order up a not only the chain but a new cassette. Cassette are a mystery on wear for sure.

What do all the minds in here think? It is not broke leave alone or just go new and be done for hopefully anther 16000 miles, not kilometres.

Deacon Mark



I believe that there is data to show that worn cassettes or chain
rings accelerate chain wear.
--
Cheers,

John B.


Duane[_7_] July 10th 20 12:15 AM

Cassette change?
 
Mark Cleary wrote:
I am easy on drive-train's. I get 6000 miles on chains without going over
the limit on 11 speed shimano. My question is right now my cassette a
11-28 has some 16000 miles on it and works fine. No Skipping I am getting
ready to put a new chain on pretty soon maybe another 1000 miles. Should
I go ahead and swap out the cassette. My instincts tell me to just keep
riding. If for some reason a new chain causes a skip then yes i need new
cassette. The bike is Ultegra 6800 and shifts like a dream. I put a new
cable on the rear today and was thinking maybe just order up a not only
the chain but a new cassette. Cassette are a mystery on wear for sure.

What do all the minds in here think? It is not broke leave alone or just
go new and be done for hopefully anther 16000 miles, not kilometres.

Deacon Mark


Experience tells me your new chain will skip when installed. Whether you
want to wait to find out is up to you. I’ve never done 6000 km on a chain,
much less 6000 miles. Any time I’ve tried to exceed the chain limits I’ve
toasted the cassette.



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:52 PM.
Home - Home - Home - Home - Home

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
CycleBanter.com