|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
I know this isn't a racing question per se, but I didn't see a
newsgroup that looked more appropriate. I'm shopping for a new road bike, and am considering a Trek Madone, Cannondale Synapse or Supersix, or Cervelo (like an R3). I'cw having a little trouble with this. Cannondale and Cervelo both seem to have frame sizes of 51 and 54 but nothing in-between. My current road bike is 52cm and that feels right. I've tried both the 51' with the seat raised and the 54' with the seat lowered. The person at the bike store who worked with me didn't really seem able to say, "You can tell if it's the right frame size if..." The 54' is too tall, even with the seat lowered, while the 51' feels a bit too cramped. I know that comfort (since I'm not trying to race any more) is important but there are multiple adjustments that could be made, like stem height, to make the right sized frame feel more comfortable. Is there any good technique beyond standing over the top tube and assessing how much space there is between the bike and the rider to determine if I'm choosing the right frame size? There are probably bike shops where I could get more help with this but I haven't found any yet in my area. Thanks. Ken |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
On Dec 14, 2:04*pm, OccasionalFlyer wrote:
I know this isn't a racing question per se, but I didn't see a newsgroup that looked more appropriate. *I'm shopping for a new road bike, and am considering a Trek Madone, Cannondale Synapse or Supersix, or Cervelo (like an R3). *I'cw having a little trouble with this. *Cannondale and Cervelo both seem to have frame sizes of 51 and 54 but nothing in-between. My current road bike is 52cm and that feels right. *I've tried both the 51' with the seat raised and the 54' with the seat lowered. *The person at the bike store who worked with me didn't really seem able to say, "You can tell if it's the right frame size if..." *The 54' is too tall, even with the seat lowered, while the 51' feels a bit too cramped. *I know that comfort (since I'm not trying to race any more) is important but there are multiple adjustments that could be made, like stem height, to make the right sized frame feel more comfortable. *Is there any good technique beyond standing over the top tube and assessing how much space there is between the bike and the rider to determine if I'm choosing the right frame size? *There are probably bike shops where I could get more help with this but I haven't found any yet in my area. *Thanks. Ken Find a bike shop that doesn't size frames by standover height. That's irrelevant. Measure the TOP tube length of your existing bike (and the stem length) and compare to the spec of bikes you are trying out. Is there a fit problem with your existing bike that you are trying to rectify? If not, you can try to make the new bike duplicate the old position. In any case the main variables you should be looking at are saddle to bottom bracket distance (adjustable), saddle to bars reach (depends on length of top tube), and saddle to bar drop (depends on how much you raised the seat). The latter two can be adjusted by changing the stem length and angle, but if you have to do anything unusual with the stem, it's typically a sign the frame doesn't fit. Don't forget that as a Fat Master you often don't want or can't fit a saddle-bar drop as large as you may have been able to tolerate when you were young and beautiful (Jobst Brandt's phrase). I would scold you to ask this on rec.bicycles.tech (or search the archives) but I don't think they ride over there any more. Fredmaster Ben |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
In article
, OccasionalFlyer wrote: I know this isn't a racing question per se, but I didn't see a newsgroup that looked more appropriate. I'm shopping for a new road bike, and am considering a Trek Madone, Cannondale Synapse or Supersix, or Cervelo (like an R3). I'cw having a little trouble with this. Cannondale and Cervelo both seem to have frame sizes of 51 and 54 but nothing in-between. My current road bike is 52cm and that feels right. I've tried both the 51' with the seat raised and the 54' with the seat lowered. The person at the bike store who worked with me didn't really seem able to say, "You can tell if it's the right frame size if..." The 54' is too tall, even with the seat lowered, while the 51' feels a bit too cramped. I know that comfort (since I'm not trying to race any more) is important but there are multiple adjustments that could be made, like stem height, to make the right sized frame feel more comfortable. Is there any good technique beyond standing over the top tube and assessing how much space there is between the bike and the rider to determine if I'm choosing the right frame size? There are probably bike shops where I could get more help with this but I haven't found any yet in my area. Thanks. As with all of usenet, there are blowhards and biased views on rec.bicycles.tech. Nevertheless it is a good place to ask. Fitting a bicycle is complicated. Depends on your physique including strength; flexibility; will to adopt a full racing posture; and relative lengths of arms, torso, inseam, femur, and calf. Stand over height is totally irrelevant. You need your weight over the pedals so that when pedaling resolutely you are not forcing yourself forward or backward. Once that is set you fit the top tube. Longer is better up to a point. Then you fine adjust with the stem length, bar height, saddle height, saddle set-back, and saddle angle; changing each very slightly one at a time. -- Michael Press |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
On Dec 14, 3:04*pm, OccasionalFlyer wrote:
I know this isn't a racing question per se, but I didn't see a newsgroup that looked more appropriate. *I'm shopping for a new road bike, and am considering a Trek Madone, Cannondale Synapse or Supersix, or Cervelo (like an R3). *I'cw having a little trouble with this. *Cannondale and Cervelo both seem to have frame sizes of 51 and 54 but nothing in-between. My current road bike is 52cm and that feels right. *I've tried both the 51' with the seat raised and the 54' with the seat lowered. *The person at the bike store who worked with me didn't really seem able to say, "You can tell if it's the right frame size if..." *The 54' is too tall, even with the seat lowered, while the 51' feels a bit too cramped. *I know that comfort (since I'm not trying to race any more) is important but there are multiple adjustments that could be made, like stem height, to make the right sized frame feel more comfortable. *Is there any good technique beyond standing over the top tube and assessing how much space there is between the bike and the rider to determine if I'm choosing the right frame size? *There are probably bike shops where I could get more help with this but I haven't found any yet in my area. *Thanks. Ouch. What is your general location? Maybe someone here knows of a real "pro" shop in your general area. --D-y |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
On Dec 14, 7:58*pm, --D-y wrote:
On Dec 14, 3:04*pm, OccasionalFlyer wrote: I know this isn't a racing question per se, but I didn't see a newsgroup that looked more appropriate. *I'm shopping for a new road bike, and am considering a Trek Madone, Cannondale Synapse or Supersix, or Cervelo (like an R3). *I'cw having a little trouble with this. *Cannondale and Cervelo both seem to have frame sizes of 51 and 54 but nothing in-between. My current road bike is 52cm and that feels right. *I've tried both the 51' with the seat raised and the 54' with the seat lowered. *The person at the bike store who worked with me didn't really seem able to say, "You can tell if it's the right frame size if..." *The 54' is too tall, even with the seat lowered, while the 51' feels a bit too cramped. *I know that comfort (since I'm not trying to race any more) is important but there are multiple adjustments that could be made, like stem height, to make the right sized frame feel more comfortable. *Is there any good technique beyond standing over the top tube and assessing how much space there is between the bike and the rider to determine if I'm choosing the right frame size? *There are probably bike shops where I could get more help with this but I haven't found any yet in my area. *Thanks. Ouch. What is your general location? Maybe someone here knows of a real "pro" shop in your general area. --D-y- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - San Gabriel Valley in southern California (between Pasadena and Pomona). I sure miss the Bicycle OUtfiiter up in Los Altos. I used to go there (and ride by there) a lot. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
OccasionalFlyer wrote:
I know this isn't a racing question per se, but I didn't see a newsgroup that looked more appropriate. I'm shopping for a new road bike, and am considering a Trek Madone, Cannondale Synapse or Supersix, or Cervelo (like an R3). I'cw having a little trouble with this. Cannondale and Cervelo both seem to have frame sizes of 51 and 54 but nothing in-between. My current road bike is 52cm and that feels right. I've tried both the 51' with the seat raised and the 54' with the seat lowered. The person at the bike store who worked with me didn't really seem able to say, "You can tell if it's the right frame size if..." The 54' is too tall, even with the seat lowered, while the 51' feels a bit too cramped. I know that comfort (since I'm not trying to race any more) is important but there are multiple adjustments that could be made, like stem height, to make the right sized frame feel more comfortable. Is there any good technique beyond standing over the top tube and assessing how much space there is between the bike and the rider to determine if I'm choosing the right frame size? There are probably bike shops where I could get more help with this but I haven't found any yet in my area. Thanks. Ken 1. Why a new road bike? Just curious - is there anything that component upgrades wouldn't fix on the frame you currently ride and, I assume, are happy with? 2. Have you considered a frame that comes in a 52cm, even if it's not on your current short list, just to see what another example of that size feels like for you? You might find it's your current 52, and not just any 52, that feels right. 3. Please note that what feels right is a slippery combination of what's right and what you're used to - that's tough to sort out, unfortunately. 4. For anything except a custom-made frame, there are likely to be compromises, or at least adjustments, to be made. Ask the shop to fit a longer stem on the 51cm frame if that's what you think it needs, or perhaps an adjustable stem. My own solution was to buy several used bikes in different sizes, fit each with an adjustable stem, and ride each for at least a few months. That's one way to sort out what you're used to from what might work better for you. I did this not only with frame size but with crank length, several handlebar dimensions, saddle position, cleat position, etc., trying to ride everything enough to get used to it and then compare. Not perfect, I realize, but I was very happy to have taken the time to do it. Most everything I bought was relatively inexpensive. I ended with my own "mix" - a custom frame because I finally figured out they didn't make what worked best for me, heavy handlebars because they were the size and shape I liked, I built my own wheels, etc., not to mention cranks that didn't agree with the formula for my leg length by a considerable amount. It's been 10-15 years since I did all that and I'm still delighted to ride that bike. Best of luck to you and hope the above is helpful in some small way. -S- |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
On Dec 15, 7:36*am, "Steve Freides" wrote:
OccasionalFlyer wrote: I know this isn't a racing question per se, but I didn't see a newsgroup that looked more appropriate. *I'm shopping for a new road bike, and am considering a Trek Madone, Cannondale Synapse or Supersix, or Cervelo (like an R3). *I'cw having a little trouble with this. *Cannondale and Cervelo both seem to have frame sizes of 51 and 54 but nothing in-between. My current road bike is 52cm and that feels right. *I've tried both the 51' with the seat raised and the 54' with the seat lowered. *The person at the bike store who worked with me didn't really seem able to say, "You can tell if it's the right frame size if..." *The 54' is too tall, even with the seat lowered, while the 51' feels a bit too cramped. *I know that comfort (since I'm not trying to race any more) is important but there are multiple adjustments that could be made, like stem height, to make the right sized frame feel more comfortable. *Is there any good technique beyond standing over the top tube and assessing how much space there is between the bike and the rider to determine if I'm choosing the right frame size? *There are probably bike shops where I could get more help with this but I haven't found any yet in my area. *Thanks. Ken 1. *Why a new road bike? *Just curious - is there anything that component upgrades wouldn't fix on the frame you currently ride and, I assume, are happy with? 2. *Have you considered a frame that comes in a 52cm, even if it's not on your current short list, just to see what another example of that size feels like for you? *You might find it's your current 52, and not just any 52, that feels right. 3. *Please note that what feels right is a slippery combination of what's right and what you're used to - that's tough to sort out, unfortunately. 4. *For anything except a custom-made frame, there are likely to be compromises, or at least adjustments, to be made. *Ask the shop to fit a longer stem on the 51cm frame if that's what you think it needs, or perhaps an adjustable stem. My own solution was to buy several used bikes in different sizes, fit each with an adjustable stem, and ride each for at least a few months. That's one way to sort out what you're used to from what might work better for you. *I did this not only with frame size but with crank length, several handlebar dimensions, saddle position, cleat position, etc., trying to ride everything enough to get used to it and then compare. *Not perfect, I realize, but I was very happy to have taken the time to do it. *Most everything I bought was relatively inexpensive. *I ended with my own "mix" - a custom frame because I finally figured out they didn't make what worked best for me, heavy handlebars because they were the size and shape I liked, I built my own wheels, etc., not to mention cranks that didn't agree with the formula for my leg length by a considerable amount. * It's been 10-15 years since I did all that and I'm still delighted to ride that bike. Best of luck to you and hope the above is helpful in some small way. Or, Plan B: Find a good custom frame builder and get a bike meant to fit you from the get-go. This can be an expensive option but I know of one local custom maker who has built for several very experienced riders in my cohort, to universal praise and satisfaction. Because that's what custom makers do, or are supposed to do, is build you something that "fits" in every meaning of the word. Or, maybe there is a shop with a "fit guru" who has successful experience in making "off the rack" customers happy. Many people can be happy with non-custom frame sizing, by (as above) choosing seatposts, stems, crank length etc. to suit their choice of production frame. One thing, I saw "not racing"; you might be happier with a more upright riding position than you've used previously. This is a big factor in choosing among custom and production frames; you want something (obviously, but...) that is comfortable and fun to ride, not something that has to be aero and quite possibly less comfy. --D-y |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
On 12/15/2011 07:00 PM, --D-y wrote:
One thing, I saw "not racing"; you might be happier with a more upright riding position than you've used previously. This is a big factor in choosing among custom and production frames; you want something (obviously, but...) that is comfortable and fun to ride, not something that has to be aero and quite possibly less comfy. A few times I've thought I'm old enough for a more upright position but as soon as I've had to cycle into a headwind I've thought sod this and gone back to a [semi] racing setup. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
--D-y wrote:
Or, Plan B: Find a good custom frame builder and get a bike meant to fit you from the get-go. This can be an expensive option but I know of one local custom maker who has built for several very experienced riders in my cohort, to universal praise and satisfaction. Because that's what custom makers do, or are supposed to do, is build you something that "fits" in every meaning of the word. Yeah, except that not everyone needs a custom frame. My saga was pretty interesting, at least to me - I started with a frame with what was supposed to be the right standover height, then kept trying bigger and bigger frame until I had one I couldn't stand over even in cycling shoes - I had to slide to one side to put a foot down - but I loved the way it rode. The custom bike I eventually ordered had a top tube several cm bigger than anything being produced in that size I could find. (NB: Interestingly, some really old bikes fit me because there was a time when they made one size of top tube for all frame sizes ...) Or, maybe there is a shop with a "fit guru" who has successful experience in making "off the rack" customers happy. Many people can be happy with non-custom frame sizing, by (as above) choosing seatposts, stems, crank length etc. to suit their choice of production frame. Even that is risky business. The guy at my LBS is a real pro at fitting people, but his suggestions just didn't and don't work for me. One thing, I saw "not racing"; you might be happier with a more upright riding position than you've used previously. This is a big factor in choosing among custom and production frames; you want something (obviously, but...) that is comfortable and fun to ride, not something that has to be aero and quite possibly less comfy. +1 to that. Drop bar have different positions just for this purpose. Find something that's comfortable for long distances on the tops and/or hoods, and that you can really tuck into on the drops - that's proper fit, IMHO. -S- |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Choosing the right frame size
Steve Freides wrote:
--D-y wrote: Or, Plan B: Find a good custom frame builder and get a bike meant to fit you from the get-go. This can be an expensive option but I know of one local custom maker who has built for several very experienced riders in my cohort, to universal praise and satisfaction. Because that's what custom makers do, or are supposed to do, is build you something that "fits" in every meaning of the word. Yeah, except that not everyone needs a custom frame. My saga was pretty interesting, at least to me - I started with a frame with what was supposed to be the right standover height, then kept trying bigger and bigger frame until I had one I couldn't stand over even in cycling shoes - I had to slide to one side to put a foot down - but I loved the way it rode. The custom bike I eventually ordered had a top tube several cm bigger than anything being produced in that size I could find. (NB: Interestingly, some really old bikes fit me because there was a time when they made one size of top tube for all frame sizes ...) Or, maybe there is a shop with a "fit guru" who has successful experience in making "off the rack" customers happy. Many people can be happy with non-custom frame sizing, by (as above) choosing seatposts, stems, crank length etc. to suit their choice of production frame. Even that is risky business. The guy at my LBS is a real pro at fitting people, but his suggestions just didn't and don't work for me. One thing, I saw "not racing"; you might be happier with a more upright riding position than you've used previously. This is a big factor in choosing among custom and production frames; you want something (obviously, but...) that is comfortable and fun to ride, not something that has to be aero and quite possibly less comfy. +1 to that. Drop bar have different positions just for this purpose. Find something that's comfortable for long distances on the tops and/or hoods, and that you can really tuck into on the drops - that's proper fit, IMHO. -S- Oops - the +1 is for the person who disagreed with you - sitting upright in the wind is only OK if it's a "townie" bike, beach cruiser, etc. A road bike means you want to be able to get reasonably aero somehow or other. -S- |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Frame sizing question: Go a size up or a size down? | kwalters | Techniques | 32 | December 11th 06 12:41 AM |
FAQ: choosing the right bike size? | Yarper | Techniques | 12 | November 17th 06 12:25 PM |
threadless fork size: one size smaller for frame size | [email protected] | Techniques | 2 | February 24th 06 03:49 AM |
help with frame size | pingin | UK | 10 | March 8th 05 10:19 PM |
size of a frame... | Maras | General | 5 | January 27th 04 06:41 PM |