|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Knee pain from SPD pedals
Two weeks after starting to use SPD pedals one of my knees is hurting
a bit. The only adjustment I know of (besides the release setting) is to move the cleat either forward or backward, whichever of the two sets of screws is not in use. I can also move ME on the bike by adjusting the seat position. Any advice appreciated. |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"dgk" wrote:
Two weeks after starting to use SPD pedals one of my knees is hurting a bit. The only adjustment I know of (besides the release setting) is to move the cleat either forward or backward, whichever of the two sets of screws is not in use. You can also adjust the angle of the cleats (i.e., to make your toes point inward, straight, or outward). That is an important adjustment. You foot position should be whatever is comfortable for you. The fore-aft cleat position should put the ball of your foot directly over the pedal axle or _slightly_ in front of the pedal axle, never behind. I can also move ME on the bike by adjusting the seat position. Any advice appreciated. Knee pain can be caused by a to high or low saddle. Too low usually results in pain in the front of the knee, and vice versa. Raise your saddle until your hips just start to rock when pedaling, and then bring it down a few mm. Pushing big gears can also cause knee pain. Art Harris |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
I my area they have a shop that does fitting for cleats also. They spend
about 45 minutes making sure you are set up right. They charge about $30. "dgk" wrote in message ... Two weeks after starting to use SPD pedals one of my knees is hurting a bit. The only adjustment I know of (besides the release setting) is to move the cleat either forward or backward, whichever of the two sets of screws is not in use. I can also move ME on the bike by adjusting the seat position. Any advice appreciated. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
dgk wrote: Two weeks after starting to use SPD pedals one of my knees is hurting a bit. The only adjustment I know of (besides the release setting) is to move the cleat either forward or backward, whichever of the two sets of screws is not in use. I can also move ME on the bike by adjusting the seat position. Any advice appreciated. I once helped install a person's first pair of clipless cleats. I was lobbying hard for the pedal axle to be under the ball of the foot (standard position). She insisted on a different position - unfortunately, I forget if she wanted her foot further forward or further back. In any case, after about 250 miles of riding, she was having significant pain under the kneecap. She then listened to me, we adjusted them so the axle was under the ball of her foot, and the pain soon went away. As others have said, the side-to-side angle is also important. If you're pigeon-toed and have your pedals adjusted duck-footed, you'll do knee damage. Cleats really do need precise adjusting, at least for many people. - Frank Krygowski |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
dgk wrote in
: Two weeks after starting to use SPD pedals one of my knees is hurting a bit. The only adjustment I know of (besides the release setting) is to move the cleat either forward or backward, whichever of the two sets of screws is not in use. I can also move ME on the bike by adjusting the seat position. Any advice appreciated. If you could provide a little more detail on the location of the pain, it would help. Top of kneecap, bottom of kneecap tendon, medial knee (inside), lateral knee (outside); each had specific causes and remedies. As noted before, some pain comes from too low a seat/large forces, some from too high a seat/overextension, some from improper seat fore and aft adjustment (on the seat post), and some from improper cleat alignment. You might want to take the advice I read somewhere and walk with wet feet across a surface that will show your footprints to get the orientation of your feet, and then differentially adjust your clips to match. You might also want to take the clips off and see just how they can be adjusted. The ones I'm familiar with allow fore and aft adjustment, both in the clip slot for the bolt head and in the shoe socket for the bolt, along with rotary positioning via knurled mating surfaces. I've fiddled around for a couple rides to get the right cleat radial adjustment. I've used Road Cycling; Gregor and Conconi, editors; Blackwell Science; ISBN 086542912X; which is a product of the IOC Medical Commission both for the general biomechanics and specific medical advice. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
dgk wrote:
Two weeks after starting to use SPD pedals one of my knees is hurting a bit. The only adjustment I know of (besides the release setting) is to move the cleat either forward or backward, whichever of the two sets of screws is not in use. I can also move ME on the bike by adjusting the seat position. Any advice appreciated. Maybe something on this site can help.... http://www.cptips.com/knee.htm |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
At Sat, 25 Jun 2005 08:49:12 -0400, message
was posted by "Arthur Harris" , including some, all or none of the following: You can also adjust the angle of the cleats (i.e., to make your toes point inward, straight, or outward). That is an important adjustment. You foot position should be whatever is comfortable for you. What Art said. In every respect - SPDs are not quite the same as platform pedals, so the saddle height will likely be subtly different, but it took me a few tries to get the adjustment right on the cleats. In the end I find that getting the inner side of the shoe parallel with the crank works for me, but it's going to be different for everyone. Guy -- May contain traces of irony. Contents liable to settle after posting. http://www.chapmancentral.co.uk 85% of helmet statistics are made up, 69% of them at CHS, Puget Sound |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Different shoes have different sole thickness, this can throw off your
seat height some, but it shouldn't be so much as to cause serious trouble. Also, it should be immediately apparent to you if your foot os too far forward or back. The problem may be in the angle of the cleat. Many people have a natural twist to their foot as they pedal, this is why many of the modern pedal cleats have a built in "float". That is, when clipped in, the shoe can twist freely slightly. This also allows a little sloppiness in setting the angle of the cleat, Too much inaccuracy, however, can lead to trouble. Ride your bike, and pay particular attention to the guilty leg. At any point of your pedal stroke does it seem like your foot is trying to twist out of the pedal? Note, this may be just a slight pressure. But it should not be pressing against either of the cleat's "float limit" anywhere during your pedal stroke. If it is, the cleat is adjusted wrong and is preventing your foot from twisting as it should. If this is so, determine which direction the pedal is "fighting" against your foot and adjust the angle of the cleat to allow your foot to twist naturally. - - "May you have the winds at your back, And a really low gear for the hills!" Chris Zacho ~ "Your Friendly Neighborhood Wheelman" Chris'Z Corner http://www.geocities.com/czcorner |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
"dgk" wrote in message ... Two weeks after starting to use SPD pedals one of my knees is hurting a bit. The only adjustment I know of (besides the release setting) is to move the cleat either forward or backward, whichever of the two sets of screws is not in use. I can also move ME on the bike by adjusting the seat position. Any advice appreciated. Thing one: changing to clipless will virtually guarantee you'll need to adjust your saddle position. Your foot is almost certainly closer to the pedal spindle than it was before, so you're extending your knee more. And since changing your saddle height automatically moves it fore or aft, there will be an effect on reach (albeit small) as well. Also, clipless pedals center your foot laterally on the pedal. Were they in the same position before? It's usually a good idea to carefully observe where your feet "want" to rest naturally on a platform type pedal (and to measure how far that position actually is from the center of the bottom bracket), so that the position imposed by the cleats isn't too radically different. The distance between the pedals is the "Q factor," and if you used to ride with your feet towards the outside of the pedals and the new ones are forcing them closer to the centerline of the bike, you may need different pedals. The angle of the foot relative to the pedal spindle is also important. If you're naturally "pigeon-toed," for example, forcing perpendicularity can cause stress on your knees. Cleats can be adjusted to accommodate a bit of an angle. Personally, I found that it was important to keep my knees a bit behind the pedal spindle, when measured as shown here in section D: http://www.coloradocyclist.com/bikefit/. If my knees were too far forward of the spindle I had knee pain. RichC |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
On Sat, 25 Jun 2005 17:41:29 -0400, "Rich Clark"
wrote: "dgk" wrote in message .. . Two weeks after starting to use SPD pedals one of my knees is hurting a bit. The only adjustment I know of (besides the release setting) is to move the cleat either forward or backward, whichever of the two sets of screws is not in use. I can also move ME on the bike by adjusting the seat position. Any advice appreciated. Thing one: changing to clipless will virtually guarantee you'll need to adjust your saddle position. Your foot is almost certainly closer to the pedal spindle than it was before, so you're extending your knee more. And since changing your saddle height automatically moves it fore or aft, there will be an effect on reach (albeit small) as well. Also, clipless pedals center your foot laterally on the pedal. Were they in the same position before? It's usually a good idea to carefully observe where your feet "want" to rest naturally on a platform type pedal (and to measure how far that position actually is from the center of the bottom bracket), so that the position imposed by the cleats isn't too radically different. The distance between the pedals is the "Q factor," and if you used to ride with your feet towards the outside of the pedals and the new ones are forcing them closer to the centerline of the bike, you may need different pedals. The angle of the foot relative to the pedal spindle is also important. If you're naturally "pigeon-toed," for example, forcing perpendicularity can cause stress on your knees. Cleats can be adjusted to accommodate a bit of an angle. Personally, I found that it was important to keep my knees a bit behind the pedal spindle, when measured as shown here in section D: http://www.coloradocyclist.com/bikefit/. If my knees were too far forward of the spindle I had knee pain. RichC Thanks to all for helping. I will search around for a place that adjusts the cleats - I have two ideas. First is the Time's Up guys next Thursday night during the repair clinic. Second is a shop run by the son (or grandson) of Francisco Cuevas, who was apparently fairly well known as a frame builder. Their shop is just a few blocks off of my normal commute home. It seems almost more of a club than a shop. However, first I'm likely to not bike at all for a few days. Someone mentioned in an earlier thread that the best thing for knee pain is to rest it. Seems like good advice. This went from me wondering whether something was hurting a bit coming home yesterday to limping around nicely today. I just iced it and it is much better, plus I'm going to take a few of those Darvocets that are left over from elbow surgery. One at a time though. I'm going to put the platform pedals back on temporarily and start off that way after it stops hurting. Hopefully that will only be a few days. I wish I could tell exactly where the pain is but it is just somewhere in the front center of the joint, a bit on the left side. I'll call the Cuevas shop and seek their advice early next week. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
"Track" vs. "road" pedals (vintage) theory | Tim McNamara | Techniques | 16 | March 16th 05 03:47 PM |
Knee creaking and upper calf muscle pain... | FaHeL | Racing | 2 | September 10th 04 02:19 PM |
Painful knee | ouch | UK | 44 | October 14th 03 10:37 PM |
Which pedals: nylon or metal? | [email protected] | General | 15 | September 2nd 03 04:04 AM |
Which pedals: nylon or metal? | [email protected] | Social Issues | 0 | August 17th 03 06:18 PM |