|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#71
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
On 2018-05-07 12:25, Ian Field wrote:
"David Scheidt" wrote in message news sms wrote: :On 5/2/2018 7:49 PM, bob prohaska wrote: : I finally caved and bought a Shimano dh-3n72 hub for use on my : exercise bike. It works fine, but the LEDs flicker quite noticeably : at all speeds. The circuit puts series trios of LEDs in inverse : parallel across the dynamo, so each trio lights on alternate half- : cycles. The flicker wasn't visible with the old Soubitez roller, : because it was working at about 6x higher frequency. The circuit is at : http://www.zefox.net/~bob/bicycle/schematic.gif : The point of the design is to eliminate rectifier losses, which are : substantial at low voltage. : : The new setup might be ok for fast riding. At low speeds and in traffic : I'm less sure I'll like it and fairly certain bystanders won't like it : at all, especially at night. As a DRL it certainly aids conspicuity 8-) : : Can anybody point me to a discussion of what outfits like B&M use in : their dynamo-powerd LED headlights? I've searched intermittenly but : never hit the right keywords. : : Thanks for reading, and any guidance. : : bob prohaska :I suspect that they use a Schottky Bridge Rectifier, with a capacitor :across the DC output, plus a couple of farads for any standlight that :switches in when stopped. I would not be at all surprised if the better stuff (where better needn't mean 'more expensive' just 'better design' or maybe just 'newer design') is using a MOSFET brige. One for a bike light wouldn't be terribly expensive, and they're substantially more efficent than a schottky is. SB rectifiers are rarely rated more than 60V - anything higher gets seriously expensive. Nah. $0.03 a pop for the 100V version in reel quatities: http://www.smc-diodes.com/propdf/DSS...73%20REV.A.pdf However, in a dynamo circuit I'd try to use active rectification. Most of that type of AC generator vaguely resemble constant current sources - the off load voltage can get a bit naughty. The open voltage on a bottle dynamo can give an impressive belt, not too sure about hub types. Clearly; an intermittent fault in the load would kill the rectifier. That's what bi-directional TVS'es are for, cheap insurance :-) -- Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ |
Ads |
#72
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
On 2018-05-08 11:50, sms wrote:
On 5/6/2018 10:01 AM, Joerg wrote: snip For me the only proper way of lighting a bicycle is with a rechargeable battery. The LEDs get clean DC and the battery can be recharged from any source, even a pulsating one. That way the lights will not dim to "stand light" or go out when waiting at a traffic light. Why should bicycle lighting be inferior to car lighting? I have dynamo wheels on several bicycles and it's nice to just go. Not worry about charging lights off the bike. I don't worry either. When I return home the bike gets plugged in just like electric cars do. Except it's only a lighting battery which charges fast. Turns off automatically but I usually unplug it before going to bed. That way both bikes are always charged. Not 100% topped off but 90% because that greatly prolongs Li-Ion life and suffices even for really long rides. OTOH the dynamo lights are not suitable for all situations. The multi-use paths around here are generally alongside creeks and are unlit, with a lot of twists and turns as they go over and under roads, waterways, and railroad tracks. You need a higher-power light, especially if you want to proceed at an expeditious pace. That is a key reson why dynamo-only will never work for me. I ride on dirt a lot of times, singletrack. There are tricky sections with loose rocks strewn around, diagonal ruts and other fun stuff. Miss one of those because the light was too dim and a nasty spill could happen. So there has to be at least a buffer battery. A sizeable one because some routes can take 2h at rather modest speeds. It would be possible to have a hub dynamo capable of powering higher power lights but there seems to be little demand for it now that there are so many Li-Ion powered high-power lights available for relatively low prices. Yeah, it's not a priority for me. On cross-country trips that would be another matter although I have seen longhaul mountain bikers who had strapped a solar panel to the front baggage roll. Recharging while rolling would be nice but the advantages are so slim that it isn't worth much expense or effort for me. -- Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ |
#73
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
Jeff Liebermann wrote:
:Assuming you own an automobile, what do you check before you go for a :ride or drive? Got enough gasoline? Fluid levels within limits? Tire I check nothing. I get in the car and drive. If the tires on the drivers side were flat, I would notice. behond that, I dont' check things before I trip. if the gas gauge says low, I put gasoline in it. I check the oil at the same time. I check the tire pressure from time to time. I observe the tail lights nd brake lihgts when I drive at night. I look at the pads when I put the snow tires on and take them off (and the shop does similar checks when they change the oil.). I expect my car to Just Work. I expect my bike to do the same. I check the tire pressure rather more often, but the pre ride checklist consists of dropping the bike frm fpour inches or so, and listening to it. Unexpected noises are investigated. They're normally "itre needs air". secon most common problem is "loose fender quick disconnect". The bike needs uch more work per mile than a car does, but they're still generally ready to ride. -- sig 112 |
#74
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
On Tuesday, May 8, 2018 at 3:43:00 PM UTC-4, Joerg wrote:
On 2018-05-08 12:01, Frank Krygowski wrote: On Tuesday, May 8, 2018 at 2:10:43 PM UTC-4, Joerg wrote: Once I waited at a red light and a Harley rider pulled up next to me. His big headlight was about the same brightness as mine except more spectrally pleasant, not as "hospital-grade" white as mine. I remain absolutely astonished that people think the headlight on a bicycle has to have the same brightness as the headlight on a motorcycle capable of 100+ mph. You as an engineer should know this: https://policedriver.com/over-driving-your-headlights/ So your 100mph statement is quite ridiculous. So is your logic. Is it a 100+ mph motorcycle? Yes, whether you like it or not, and whether you would ride it at that speed or not. Are its headlights adequate only at 60 mph? That has not been proven, because the motorcycle may have super headlights. It doesn't matter. What should be clear is that a bicycle does not need a headlight as bright as a motorcycle's. No matter how fast you pretend to be on your bike (if that's your shtick today - it flip-flops regularly) you don't need even a 45 mph light. Also, as I've said many times before I like to be seen. Since I have these bright lights I have noticed a substantial drop in cases where car drivers pull out in front of me. Objective accomplished, and at a very modest cost. You need to look up confirmation bias. And until you do, you need to buy a dozen pairs of the lucky socks I'm willing to sell you. I _know_ those are what has kept me from having any car-bike wrecks in my 40+ years of riding. I just know it! Seriously, I just never have cars pull out in front of me. Your magic is way, way weaker than mine. But is it magic? Or is it technique? - Frank Krygowski |
#75
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
On Tuesday, May 8, 2018 at 5:28:05 PM UTC-4, Joerg wrote:
1. Hardly any bike or wheel set in America has a hub dynamo. So you have to buy new spokes and spoke it in. Horrors!! Or more seriously: Too bad you a) can't find a wheel for sale using this internet thing; and b) aren't competent at wheel building. 2. When you get to an intersection, traffic light or whetever where you need to stop many of these lights eitehr go out or they enter a "stand light" mode which is rather dim. Seriously, you're terrified of someone hitting you from the _front_ when you're at a traffic light? Geez... 3. They still can't hold a candle to MagicShine and clones of it. 8W into a Cree XM-L is a different caliber than 3W. And a MagicShine can't hold a candle to an aircraft landing light. But bicycling equipment isn't about excess, it's about efficiency. It's why real cyclists don't use motorcycle gage spokes, inch wide chains, tubes with 1/8" walls, etc. 4. The StVZO lights for dynamos that I have seen have a much too sharp cut-off line which is uncomfortable on an uneven road or on the MTB. Gosh, how do you ever drive a car at night with that same sort of cut-off? 5. The prices of many of those lights are outrageous. Often fat three-digits. Yet this lowly retired professor has afforded about five of them. Sad that your economic situation is so dire. I don't want a $200 headlight on my bike only to have it ripped off by a hobo a few months later. In over 40 years of avid adult cycling, I've had two cyclometers nicked, obviously by kids who had no use for them, because Avocet mounts and senders are damned uncommon. Nothing else has ever been stolen. If you're that paranoid about the hobos in Cameron Park, use thread lock compound on security fasteners. Or move. - Frank Krygowski |
#76
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
Jeff Liebermann wrote:
On Mon, 7 May 2018 13:21:02 +0000 (UTC), David Scheidt wrote: Theodore Heise wrote: :Someone noted elsethread the great variation in user requirements, :and the choice between dynamos and rechargeables is certainly :affected by them. I need a light only infrequently, so for me a :dynamo would largely be wasted weight and clutter on the bike. On Ah, but it would just work. Get on the bike, and ride. a rechargable light would have to be found, put on the bike, and discover the batteries are dead. Assuming you own an automobile, what do you check before you go for a ride or drive? Got enough gasoline? Fluid levels within limits? Tire pressure look normal? Engine warning light on? For fanatics, does the add-on OBD II display panel show anything unusual? Having driven rolling wrecks during college, walking around the vehicle to see what has fallen off or was stolen in the night was a regular ritual. Same with my bicycles. Do you check the air pressure in your tires before riding? I don't, but I give the tires a good squeeze as a crude pressure check and pump as needed. My favorite mistakes are a loose quick release, a loose nut from an unfinished repair, and my folding pedals in the folded position. I take a quick look at the frame and gears for any sign of damage. I check for my seat bag of tricks, which contains tools, parts, munchies, and a few dollars. Batteries do not provide a visual or mechanical indication of SoC (state of charge), but you can add something like this: https://www.ebay.com/itm/Lithium-ion-Charging-Battery-Voltage-Capacity-Percent-Level-LED-Indicator-18650/181692946263 Some headlights have a similar indicator built in. I use a DVM (digital voltmeter) instead. More problematic is the tail light, which usually runs on alkaline AA or AAA cells. I haven't seen one with a SoC indicator and would not expect to see one as the added circuitry and display would probably cost more than the tail light. So, I run the alkalines until they die, and carry a few spare NiMH cells which I rotate as needed. With LSD (low self discharge) NiMH cells, they remain mostly charged for months. While just jumping onto the bicycle and going for a ride is a nice thought, the reality is that we all do some manner of pre-flight check before riding. So, why is it so painful to add a headlight battery test to the checklist? For the fun bikes I probably would check the pressures and so on, for lights less, so more likely just fit the lights which are generally have charge at least enough for a few rides. The commute bike though has two rears which I use until one looses charge, and then charge. Similar with the front light, but in generally lasts longer since it has run time of a day on low, so though I do use it as a day light, and commute hrs per week is 12hrs. I do agree though since most people change into cycling gear, that worrying about putting a light on isn’t much of a hassle really. Roger Merriman |
#77
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
Frank Krygowski wrote:
On Tuesday, May 8, 2018 at 2:10:43 PM UTC-4, Joerg wrote: Once I waited at a red light and a Harley rider pulled up next to me. His big headlight was about the same brightness as mine except more spectrally pleasant, not as "hospital-grade" white as mine. I remain absolutely astonished that people think the headlight on a bicycle has to have the same brightness as the headlight on a motorcycle capable of 100+ mph. - Frank Krygowski How bright a light looks, at a glance isn’t generally very accurate, my torch looks as bright as the light I use for MTBing in that both look bright, in terms of ooh that’s a bright light. Motorbike lights generally don’t tend to be terribly powerful, for a combination of reasons. One of the main reasons, is mostly motorbikes aren’t used after dark. My commute bike I have one of the Exposure Strada 600 it has a shaped beam not German standard but certainly intended not to blind, and a remote switch, so I generally run it on low and only kick up if needed, which is remarkably few places, on my commute. As ever mileage varies the 1000 lumen MTB light in certain places can feel under powered, though that’s far from norm, even off road I don’t generally use it at full chat, though does depend on where, wide tracks etc are a easy low setting, it’s only low speed twisty stuff that needs the full power, which is also where the only MTB dynamo light fell down, ie it could push out the power at higher speeds where generally you don’t need that much power, but reduces on the slower technical stuff, where you really do! Roger Merriman |
#78
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
On 2018-05-08 20:23, Frank Krygowski wrote:
On Tuesday, May 8, 2018 at 5:28:05 PM UTC-4, Joerg wrote: 1. Hardly any bike or wheel set in America has a hub dynamo. So you have to buy new spokes and spoke it in. Horrors!! Or more seriously: Too bad you a) can't find a wheel for sale using this internet thing; and b) aren't competent at wheel building. Your usual premature conclusions. I am very particular about what quality wheel I want. I know how to build a wheel but I don't want to do it. Simple, really. 2. When you get to an intersection, traffic light or whetever where you need to stop many of these lights eitehr go out or they enter a "stand light" mode which is rather dim. Seriously, you're terrified of someone hitting you from the _front_ when you're at a traffic light? Geez... I know you don't understand these things but there are drivers who come tearing around on a left turn cutting across the "empty" left turn lane of the road on the left. To the point where the yellow lines have worn. There are reasons for vehicle lights. A bicycle is a vehicle. 3. They still can't hold a candle to MagicShine and clones of it. 8W into a Cree XM-L is a different caliber than 3W. And a MagicShine can't hold a candle to an aircraft landing light. But bicycling equipment isn't about excess, it's about efficiency. It's why real cyclists don't use motorcycle gage spokes, inch wide chains, tubes with 1/8" walls, etc. A lot of cyclists simply do not understand it and you seem to be one. Those that I convinced of the advantages of thick tubes were elated about the sudden absence of flats. 4. The StVZO lights for dynamos that I have seen have a much too sharp cut-off line which is uncomfortable on an uneven road or on the MTB. Gosh, how do you ever drive a car at night with that same sort of cut-off? Mine does not have such sharp cut-off as I sah in StVZO bike lights and its suspension is a lot harder than on the bike. Also, look at your steering column items and you might discover something very practical: High beam. Something bike manufacturers don't seem to understand. Get it now? 5. The prices of many of those lights are outrageous. Often fat three-digits. Yet this lowly retired professor has afforded about five of them. Sad that your economic situation is so dire. I tend not to waste money. Comments like yours made me understand why so many people can't get out of debt even by the time they retire. They can't manage money. I don't want a $200 headlight on my bike only to have it ripped off by a hobo a few months later. In over 40 years of avid adult cycling, I've had two cyclometers nicked, obviously by kids who had no use for them, because Avocet mounts and senders are damned uncommon. Nothing else has ever been stolen. If you're that paranoid about the hobos in Cameron Park, use thread lock compound on security fasteners. Or move. I've had whole bikes stolen, gone, never recovered. -- Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ |
#79
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
On 2018-05-08 20:13, Frank Krygowski wrote:
On Tuesday, May 8, 2018 at 3:43:00 PM UTC-4, Joerg wrote: On 2018-05-08 12:01, Frank Krygowski wrote: On Tuesday, May 8, 2018 at 2:10:43 PM UTC-4, Joerg wrote: Once I waited at a red light and a Harley rider pulled up next to me. His big headlight was about the same brightness as mine except more spectrally pleasant, not as "hospital-grade" white as mine. I remain absolutely astonished that people think the headlight on a bicycle has to have the same brightness as the headlight on a motorcycle capable of 100+ mph. You as an engineer should know this: https://policedriver.com/over-driving-your-headlights/ So your 100mph statement is quite ridiculous. So is your logic. Is it a 100+ mph motorcycle? Doesn't matter whether a car or a motorcycle. Going 100mph with regular headlights is reckless. ... Yes, whether you like it or not, and whether you would ride it at that speed or not. Huh? Are its headlights adequate only at 60 mph? That has not been proven, because the motorcycle may have super headlights. They generally don't. Sit on one and look. It doesn't matter. This statement makes any further discussion fruitless. [...] -- Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ |
#80
|
|||
|
|||
Dynamo/LED power conditioning
Joerg wrote:
On Tuesday, May 8, 2018 at 2:10:43 PM UTC-4, Joerg wrote: Once I waited at a red light and a Harley rider pulled up next to me. His big headlight was about the same brightness as This statement makes any further discussion fruitless. IFTFY. EOD. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
conditioning question | teachndad | Unicycling | 6 | September 9th 08 08:18 PM |
New Brooks B17 Conditioning Question | [email protected] | Techniques | 46 | October 9th 06 05:10 PM |
Dynamo on a Uni for GPS/PPC power | mikepenton | Unicycling | 15 | February 3rd 05 04:50 PM |
Conditioning/Getting in shape | Bent Pedals | Recumbent Biking | 23 | October 19th 03 09:48 PM |
Stretching & Physical Conditioning links | Luther Blissett | Australia | 2 | August 27th 03 02:25 PM |