|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
I managed to grind the bearings in my '96 9 spd record hub into a fine
paste. Can I use any Campy 9/10 freehub body as a replacement? |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
Qui si parla Campagnolo wrote: 1997 freehub, the first year for 9s. Cannot use a 'modern' from 1998-today 9/10s freehub body, must use a 1997 freehub body, Ah. The story of my life. Thanks for the info. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
On 16 Oct 2005 06:39:14 -0700, "Qui si parla Campagnolo"
wrote: wrote: I managed to grind the bearings in my '96 9 spd record hub into a fine paste. Can I use any Campy 9/10 freehub body as a replacement? 1997 freehub, the first year for 9s. Cannot use a 'modern' from 1998-today 9/10s freehub body, must use a 1997 freehub body, which we have for $95. So... just out of curiosity, is that somehow more justified than the occasional Shimano incompatibility between parts? From reading this group, I truly do not get the impression that Shimano or Campa are all that far apart in making new stuff incompatible with the old stuff. Jasper |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
Jasper Janssen schrieb:
On 16 Oct 2005 06:39:14 -0700, "Qui si parla Campagnolo" wrote: wrote: I managed to grind the bearings in my '96 9 spd record hub into a fine paste. Can I use any Campy 9/10 freehub body as a replacement? 1997 freehub, the first year for 9s. Cannot use a 'modern' from 1998-today 9/10s freehub body, must use a 1997 freehub body, which we have for $95. So... just out of curiosity, is that somehow more justified than the occasional Shimano incompatibility between parts? From reading this group, I truly do not get the impression that Shimano or Campa are all that far apart in making new stuff incompatible with the old stuff. Jasper Vice/Versa The 8spd. (Exadrive) casettes fit on the freehub body of the rearhubs Record, Chorus and Athena (the newer hubs with the alu. axles) |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
On Mon, 17 Oct 2005 06:39:36 +0200, Volker Leimann
wrote: Jasper Janssen schrieb: On 16 Oct 2005 06:39:14 -0700, "Qui si parla Campagnolo" wrote: wrote: I managed to grind the bearings in my '96 9 spd record hub into a fine paste. Can I use any Campy 9/10 freehub body as a replacement? 1997 freehub, the first year for 9s. Cannot use a 'modern' from 1998-today 9/10s freehub body, must use a 1997 freehub body, which we have for $95. So... just out of curiosity, is that somehow more justified than the occasional Shimano incompatibility between parts? From reading this group, I truly do not get the impression that Shimano or Campa are all that far apart in making new stuff incompatible with the old stuff. Vice/Versa The 8spd. (Exadrive) casettes fit on the freehub body of the rearhubs Record, Chorus and Athena (the newer hubs with the alu. axles) On the other hand, the '04-'06 DA hub (but not the cassette) excepted, all Shimano cassettes fit on all Shimano hubs, even if the freehub bodies themselves are occasionally incompatible. Jasper |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
Jasper Janssen wrote: On 16 Oct 2005 06:39:14 -0700, "Qui si parla Campagnolo" wrote: wrote: I managed to grind the bearings in my '96 9 spd record hub into a fine paste. Can I use any Campy 9/10 freehub body as a replacement? 1997 freehub, the first year for 9s. Cannot use a 'modern' from 1998-today 9/10s freehub body, must use a 1997 freehub body, which we have for $95. So... just out of curiosity, is that somehow more justified than the occasional Shimano incompatibility between parts? From reading this group, I truly do not get the impression that Shimano or Campa are all that far apart in making new stuff incompatible with the old stuff. Jasper Each freehub for shimano is different and oft-times not compatible with each other. That way mostly since 1997 and intro of 9s...Cannot put a 9s ultegra freehub body onto a DA hub w/o changing cones, etc. At least Campagnolo has the same freehub body for the top three hubs, has since 1999, and the same for the lower three, same since 1999.... Now you see a whole new compatibility issue for DA and 10s...hub part wise. In a coupe of years, try to find a DA 9s freehub body...At least Campagnolo 1997 9s freehub bodies are still being made, available from Quality and others. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
On 17 Oct 2005 05:58:19 -0700, "Qui si parla Campagnolo"
wrote: Jasper Janssen wrote: So... just out of curiosity, is that somehow more justified than the occasional Shimano incompatibility between parts? From reading this group, I truly do not get the impression that Shimano or Campa are all that far apart in making new stuff incompatible with the old stuff. Each freehub for shimano is different and oft-times not compatible with each other. That way mostly since 1997 and intro of 9s...Cannot put a 9s ultegra freehub body onto a DA hub w/o changing cones, etc. At least Campagnolo has the same freehub body for the top three hubs, has since 1999, and the same for the lower three, same since 1999.... My impression is that DA is, a lot of the time, not compatible with anything whereas the rest is pretty much interchangeable, so that DA is for those who want expensive crap they have to replace on a regular basis and the rest of the stuff is for regular riders -- as opposed to Campy, where Record means not only ultra-light high performance stuff but also very durable stuff. Different philosophies clashing. As far as the specific issue is concerned: AFAIK all the freehub bodies are in fact identical (aside from the early, non-replaceable ones, Silent Clutch, presumably some DA stuff, and the division 'tween 7 and 8+), but the dustcap on them exists with three different internal sizes depending on the external size of the cone. Dustcaps in all sizes are available from various retailers. Now you see a whole new compatibility issue for DA and 10s...hub part wise. In a coupe of years, try to find a DA 9s freehub body...At least Campagnolo 1997 9s freehub bodies are still being made, available from Quality and others. Hmm. Well, but why would you want a DA 9s freehub body, when by the time it wears out the STIs have fallen apart as a signal it's time to move to 10s or 12s? Jasper |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Are all Campy freehub bodies the same
Jasper Janssen wrote: On 17 Oct 2005 05:58:19 -0700, "Qui si parla Campagnolo" wrote: Jasper Janssen wrote: So... just out of curiosity, is that somehow more justified than the occasional Shimano incompatibility between parts? From reading this group, I truly do not get the impression that Shimano or Campa are all that far apart in making new stuff incompatible with the old stuff. Each freehub for shimano is different and oft-times not compatible with each other. That way mostly since 1997 and intro of 9s...Cannot put a 9s ultegra freehub body onto a DA hub w/o changing cones, etc. At least Campagnolo has the same freehub body for the top three hubs, has since 1999, and the same for the lower three, same since 1999.... My impression is that DA is, a lot of the time, not compatible with anything whereas the rest is pretty much interchangeable, so that DA is for those who want expensive crap they have to replace on a regular basis and the rest of the stuff is for regular riders -- as opposed to Campy, where Record means not only ultra-light high performance stuff but also very durable stuff. Different philosophies clashing. As far as the specific issue is concerned: AFAIK all the freehub bodies are in fact identical (aside from the early, non-replaceable ones, Silent Clutch, presumably some DA stuff, and the division 'tween 7 and 8+), but the dustcap on them exists with three different internal sizes depending on the external size of the cone. Dustcaps in all sizes are available from various retailers. Now you see a whole new compatibility issue for DA and 10s...hub part wise. In a coupe of years, try to find a DA 9s freehub body...At least Campagnolo 1997 9s freehub bodies are still being made, available from Quality and others. Hmm. Well, but why would you want a DA 9s freehub body, when by the time it wears out the STIs have fallen apart as a signal it's time to move to 10s or 12s? Bing, bing, bing, we have a winner....ohmygosh, we are agreeing on something. Jasper |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
replacing campy freehub | Charles Beristain | Techniques | 3 | February 3rd 05 05:38 PM |
135mm Campy Freehub Compatible Axle? | jts628 | Techniques | 2 | January 17th 05 06:21 AM |
campy freehub body... replace with shimano compatible? | Charles Beristain | Techniques | 5 | December 28th 04 12:36 AM |
Replacing bearings in Campy 1999 nine speed freehub | [email protected] | Techniques | 16 | October 8th 04 09:49 PM |
WTT: Mavic Ksyrium freehub body - Campy for Shimano | Mauiguy | Marketplace | 0 | March 23rd 04 02:21 AM |