|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#51
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
On Saturday, May 23, 2020 at 1:22:29 AM UTC+1, jbeattie wrote:
On Friday, May 22, 2020 at 12:55:41 PM UTC-7, Axel Reichert wrote: Frank Krygowski writes: the Appalachians. Like most bike tourists, I found they were much tougher than the Rockies, even though not nearly as high. Passes we rode in the Rockies tended to be very long, but mostly moderate grades. The Appalachian climbs are often much, much steeper, and when you've conquered one, you're immediately looking at another. Well, steepness correlates negatively with the length of a climb. I played around with pass statistics a lot using the data from http://www.salite.ch/struttura/default.asp?ultime=10 a huge database of 12000 (mostly European) climbs. Unfortunately the English and German versions are broken for quite some time, so a working knowledge of Italian helps. An interesting question is: Which is the steepest climb for a given length or (equivalent) the longest for a given average gradient? There are not many of these "Pareto-dominant" (the mathematical concept behind the question) climbs, some nice examples (this is not anecdotal evident, but measured numbers). - The village of Buitonne in Switzerland can be reached from the Rhone valley. It is 2.92 km with an average gradient of 20.1 %. You read that right. Riding this was quite an experience. - In Italy there is Pozza/San Glisente, a dead-end road of 8.2 km with 17.7 %. - In Austria there a five climbs from the Ziller valley to a panorama ridge road. All sport 10 km 10 %. Try all for a nice day trip. - In the US, there is Mount Washington with 12.4 km at 11.5 %. It is the ONLY listed mainland US climb with a difficulty index (sum of L * p^2 over all sections, L being the length of the section, p the gradient in percent) higher than 1200 (still bread and butter in the Alps, see below). - In Sicily, there is the volcano Etna with 40 km at 7.3 %. - In Spain, El Teide, with 63.7 km at 3.6 % (sounds like Rockies ...) - In the Andes, Conococha with 117.2 km at 3.5 %. There are NO famous climbs ridden in Le Tour, Giro or Vuelta present in this Pareto list. The toughest fully paved one in France is the ski station Val Thorens with 1396. All five climbs in the Ziller valley (above) are above 1400. The Monte Grappa in Italy alone offers 9 climbs from about 1200 up to 1700. Italy has 28 climbs tougher than 1500, up to 2700 (this is Pozza from above). For comparison, the highest pass in the Alps, the Col de l'Iseran (48 km at 4.1 %, steepest kilometer at 7 %) has a difficulty of a meagre 1094. The oh so famous L'Alpe d'Huez has only 1/3 of the length of the Etna (see above), but roughly the same gradient. 913 difficulty is the result, which is a Joe Average for the Alps. There are literally hundreds of climbs more difficult. On average, the French climbs are the easiest in the Alps (corollary: Le Tour must have the best marketing), then comes Switzerland. Austria builds tough roads, and the Italian roads are sometimes crazy. In all of the Alps there are only 5 paved passes 10 km AND 10 %. Most of the really difficult stuff are dead-ends. Now I am very interested to learn which US climbs might have a L * p^2 difficulty higher than 1000. 5 km at 20 %, 10 km at 10 %, or 40 km at 5 % will do. And all climbs more difficult than, say, 1500 (a very rare breed) will imprint a lasting memory into your brain. Looking forward to your input! Best regards Axel P. S.: Mouna Kea, Onion Valley Road, Mount Baldy and Mount Evans get over 1000. Powder Mountain is a hard climb in Salt Lake. https://pjammcycling.com/climb/93.Powder%20Mountain It has some ridiculous pitches. It goes to a ski resort, and I wouldn't want to drive it in the winter for fear of flying off a cliff descending. I'm too old for the uber-hard climbs. You get to the 20% grades, and its just not fun. You run out of gears and just grind along until you say "f*** this." At least in the Alps you get some great scenery. Onion Valley and some of the So Cal climbs are just grueling, brown, hot and not particularly scenic. The grades are not that steep in the Oregon Cascades, but at least you get some nice scenery, and the elevation is not terrible O2-wise. When I go ride with my son in Salt Lake, I'm panting like some asthmatic pug.. My son slows down and keeps saying "are you alright?" Yes, damn it! Must .. . . keep . . . riding. -- Jay Beattie. Like Jobst would say if he were he "Man up!" -- AJ No, seriously. On my now defunct blog I had some obits and memories of Jobst by people who'd known him for decades -- and virtually everyone mentioned his attitudes on various Death Rides, and how he would suddenly, on a road bike, without warning dive off the road and go cross-country (there was one amazing photograph which showed a crazily dangerous if short descent into a pool about thirty feet almost straight down from the road, with Jobst standing in the pool holding his bike up above the water, less crazy cyclists looking down from the road), or wouldn't stop for a hamburger when people were collapsing around him. He'd straighten you out in a jiffy. |
Ads |
#52
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
On Saturday, May 23, 2020 at 2:22:29 AM UTC+2, jbeattie wrote:
On Friday, May 22, 2020 at 12:55:41 PM UTC-7, Axel Reichert wrote: Frank Krygowski writes: the Appalachians. Like most bike tourists, I found they were much tougher than the Rockies, even though not nearly as high. Passes we rode in the Rockies tended to be very long, but mostly moderate grades. The Appalachian climbs are often much, much steeper, and when you've conquered one, you're immediately looking at another. Well, steepness correlates negatively with the length of a climb. I played around with pass statistics a lot using the data from http://www.salite.ch/struttura/default.asp?ultime=10 a huge database of 12000 (mostly European) climbs. Unfortunately the English and German versions are broken for quite some time, so a working knowledge of Italian helps. An interesting question is: Which is the steepest climb for a given length or (equivalent) the longest for a given average gradient? There are not many of these "Pareto-dominant" (the mathematical concept behind the question) climbs, some nice examples (this is not anecdotal evident, but measured numbers). - The village of Buitonne in Switzerland can be reached from the Rhone valley. It is 2.92 km with an average gradient of 20.1 %. You read that right. Riding this was quite an experience. - In Italy there is Pozza/San Glisente, a dead-end road of 8.2 km with 17.7 %. - In Austria there a five climbs from the Ziller valley to a panorama ridge road. All sport 10 km 10 %. Try all for a nice day trip. - In the US, there is Mount Washington with 12.4 km at 11.5 %. It is the ONLY listed mainland US climb with a difficulty index (sum of L * p^2 over all sections, L being the length of the section, p the gradient in percent) higher than 1200 (still bread and butter in the Alps, see below). - In Sicily, there is the volcano Etna with 40 km at 7.3 %. - In Spain, El Teide, with 63.7 km at 3.6 % (sounds like Rockies ...) - In the Andes, Conococha with 117.2 km at 3.5 %. There are NO famous climbs ridden in Le Tour, Giro or Vuelta present in this Pareto list. The toughest fully paved one in France is the ski station Val Thorens with 1396. All five climbs in the Ziller valley (above) are above 1400. The Monte Grappa in Italy alone offers 9 climbs from about 1200 up to 1700. Italy has 28 climbs tougher than 1500, up to 2700 (this is Pozza from above). For comparison, the highest pass in the Alps, the Col de l'Iseran (48 km at 4.1 %, steepest kilometer at 7 %) has a difficulty of a meagre 1094. The oh so famous L'Alpe d'Huez has only 1/3 of the length of the Etna (see above), but roughly the same gradient. 913 difficulty is the result, which is a Joe Average for the Alps. There are literally hundreds of climbs more difficult. On average, the French climbs are the easiest in the Alps (corollary: Le Tour must have the best marketing), then comes Switzerland. Austria builds tough roads, and the Italian roads are sometimes crazy. In all of the Alps there are only 5 paved passes 10 km AND 10 %. Most of the really difficult stuff are dead-ends. Now I am very interested to learn which US climbs might have a L * p^2 difficulty higher than 1000. 5 km at 20 %, 10 km at 10 %, or 40 km at 5 % will do. And all climbs more difficult than, say, 1500 (a very rare breed) will imprint a lasting memory into your brain. Looking forward to your input! Best regards Axel P. S.: Mouna Kea, Onion Valley Road, Mount Baldy and Mount Evans get over 1000. Powder Mountain is a hard climb in Salt Lake. https://pjammcycling.com/climb/93.Powder%20Mountain It has some ridiculous pitches. It goes to a ski resort, and I wouldn't want to drive it in the winter for fear of flying off a cliff descending. I'm too old for the uber-hard climbs. You get to the 20% grades, and its just not fun. You run out of gears and just grind along until you say "f*** this." At least in the Alps you get some great scenery. Onion Valley and some of the So Cal climbs are just grueling, brown, hot and not particularly scenic. The grades are not that steep in the Oregon Cascades, but at least you get some nice scenery, and the elevation is not terrible O2-wise. When I go ride with my son in Salt Lake, I'm panting like some asthmatic pug.. My son slows down and keeps saying "are you alright?" Yes, damn it! Must .. . . keep . . . riding. -- Jay Beattie. +1 I'm done with the stupid steep climbs with no view. The last one was the Mortirolo. What a stupid climb was that. A goat path through a forrest. I remember the Kitzbuhler Horn in the mist. 1250 m elevation gain in 9.7 km and nothing to see. Next time I will bring my gravel bike with the proper gearing. Austria has a lot a hard climbs. Lou |
#53
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
writes:
+1 I'm done with the stupid steep climbs with no view. The last one was the Mortirolo. What a stupid climb was that. A goat path through a forrest. I remember the Kitzbuhler Horn in the mist. 1250 m elevation gain in 9.7 km and nothing to see. Two mistakes on your side. (-; On the Mortirolo (I assume you came up the classic ramp from Mazzo or Tovo) do not directly go downhill to Monno, but rather take the beautiful, quiet and scenic ridge to the southwest, which offers alternating sight into both valleys. http://brouter.de/brouter-web/#map=1...46,46. 169124 The Kitzbuehler Horn in fact is a great panorama road. If you go all the way up to the radio station at the summit, you will have terrific view all around. Unless, that is, you do this in the mist ... Next time! -- -X- | in memoriam John Conway --X | 1937-2020 XXX | A glider from his "Game of Life" |
#54
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
On Saturday, May 23, 2020 at 10:52:19 AM UTC+2, Axel Reichert wrote:
writes: +1 I'm done with the stupid steep climbs with no view. The last one was the Mortirolo. What a stupid climb was that. A goat path through a forrest. I remember the Kitzbuhler Horn in the mist. 1250 m elevation gain in 9.7 km and nothing to see. Two mistakes on your side. (-; On the Mortirolo (I assume you came up the classic ramp from Mazzo or Tovo) do not directly go downhill to Monno, but rather take the beautiful, quiet and scenic ridge to the southwest, which offers alternating sight into both valleys. http://brouter.de/brouter-web/#map=1...46,46. 169124 We started in Bormio to Mazzo, Mortirolo, downhill to Monno, Ponte di Legno, Gavia and downhill to Bormio again. A brutal ride was that. The Kitzbuehler Horn in fact is a great panorama road. If you go all the way up to the radio station at the summit, you will have terrific view all around. Unless, that is, you do this in the mist ... Next time! The problem with Austria is that it is difficult to do roundtrips from one base camp. That is what we do. Best place so far to do that are Corvara in the dolomites and Barcelonette in France. Lou |
#55
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
jbeattie writes:
https://pjammcycling.com/climb/93.Powder%20Mountain Thanks, great site. Now do you know what "Fiets" in the "Climbing Card" on that page means? It is Dutch for "bicycle" and the name of the magazine which "invented" the formula for the climbing difficulty! Indeed you will find at the bottom of https://pjammcycling.com/zone/80.Wor...Cycling-Climbs the reference and the used formula. It includes some absolute height correction for lack of oxygen. This makes sense if you go very high, but I would start this only 2000 m above sea level, not 1000 m. With this site I am now able to answer my original question myself (assuming that pjammcycling.com is as well maintained for the US as salite.ch is for Europe). (-: Omitting the height correction (for better comparison with salite.ch), we get the following list of 18 climbs with a difficulty of at least 1000 in the US: 1000 Guardsman Pass 1020 Mineral King Road 1030 Dawson Saddle 1040 Sherman Pass 1060 Whitney Portal 1070 Mt Equinox 1080 Powder Mountain 1080 White Mountain 1100 Nate Harrison Grade 1120 Mauna Loa 1160 Horseshoe Meadows 1250 Onion Valley 1260 Waipoli Road 1400 Kaloko Drive 1450 Pikes Peak 1620 Haleakala 1730 Mount Washington 2620 Mauna Kea So there are 7 above 1200, 3 above 1500, and 1 above 2000 for half a continent plus an archipelago 3000 km off-shore. In the Alps there are 183 above 1200, 54 above 1500, 10 above 2000 for an area the size of South Dakota. This is not about bragging rights, I just got locked into my statistics mode and wanted to share the results. It helped me to put some data on things of which I previously had only anecdotal evidence. (-; Best regards Axel -- -X- | in memoriam John Conway --X | 1937-2020 XXX | A glider from his "Game of Life" |
#56
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
|
#57
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
On Saturday, May 23, 2020 at 2:16:55 PM UTC+2, Axel Reichert wrote:
writes: Ponte di Legno, Gavia Ah, the Gavia, so beautiful. I have to do the southern side, though, only did it from Bormio (after Stelvio). A brutal ride was that I can imagine! roundtrips from one base camp. That is what we do. Best place so far to do that are Corvara in the dolomites and Barcelonette in France. Cortina d'Ampezzo? Briancon? Bolzano? Merano? And, especially, Andermatt? Axel Yes Cortina d'Ampezzo. Briancon also. Bolzano is OK. I passed through Merano on a one way trip. Hmmm. Andermatt definitely. I once stayed in Innertkirchen for a long weekend. Grimsel, Furka and Susten the first day and the same passes the other way round the other (third) day. Spectacular views. Andermatt is on that route if I recall correctly. Lou, going for a recovery ride dead flat. No high way overpasses and ferry ramps ;-) |
#58
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
|
#59
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
On Saturday, May 23, 2020 at 4:27:21 AM UTC-7, Axel Reichert wrote:
jbeattie writes: https://pjammcycling.com/climb/93.Powder%20Mountain Thanks, great site. Now do you know what "Fiets" in the "Climbing Card" on that page means? It is Dutch for "bicycle" and the name of the magazine which "invented" the formula for the climbing difficulty! Indeed you will find at the bottom of https://pjammcycling.com/zone/80.Wor...Cycling-Climbs the reference and the used formula. It includes some absolute height correction for lack of oxygen. This makes sense if you go very high, but I would start this only 2000 m above sea level, not 1000 m. With this site I am now able to answer my original question myself (assuming that pjammcycling.com is as well maintained for the US as salite.ch is for Europe). (-: Omitting the height correction (for better comparison with salite.ch), we get the following list of 18 climbs with a difficulty of at least 1000 in the US: 1000 Guardsman Pass 1020 Mineral King Road 1030 Dawson Saddle 1040 Sherman Pass 1060 Whitney Portal 1070 Mt Equinox 1080 Powder Mountain 1080 White Mountain 1100 Nate Harrison Grade 1120 Mauna Loa 1160 Horseshoe Meadows 1250 Onion Valley 1260 Waipoli Road 1400 Kaloko Drive 1450 Pikes Peak 1620 Haleakala 1730 Mount Washington 2620 Mauna Kea So there are 7 above 1200, 3 above 1500, and 1 above 2000 for half a continent plus an archipelago 3000 km off-shore. In the Alps there are 183 above 1200, 54 above 1500, 10 above 2000 for an area the size of South Dakota. This is not about bragging rights, I just got locked into my statistics mode and wanted to share the results. It helped me to put some data on things of which I previously had only anecdotal evidence. (-; Best regards Axel The Alps are spectacular geologically and topographically, but more importantly, people have been building roads and social paths through them for thousands of years. Our highest mountains are in Alaska under snow and many smaller ranges that are Alps-ish, like the Tetons, don't have roads through them. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...nd_tetons..jpg You're not going to get the closing sequence of Sound of Music with a musical family fleeing from one cattle ranch in Wyoming to another. They would be jumping on a plane in Casper headed to the Grand Ole Opry in Nashville. That list of US climbs starts with Guardsman Pass in Utah. That's a soul sucking climb from the Park City side for an old guy, particularly since its all at elevation. By the way, watch your brakes on the way down: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hRM3bFXlyNk Knowing that there were 100 of those would not make me feel any better. I'd go to the Alps for the views and the fact that they are such a social place -- that would be the draw. I'm going to do that when the plague ends. Maybe play the alpine horns and wear lederhosen -- be an annoying US tourist, rent a bike and go creep up some pass and drink beer at the top. Pet a cow with a bell on it and do a selfie. IMO, just getting elevation is neurotic. My son lives in SLC (and was on the Tour of Utah media crew the year after that crash on Guardsman) and has a friend who did 32,000 feet of climbing (divide by three) on a neighborhood street -- over and over just to get his Everest and a bit more. Last weekend,the same guy did Little Cottonwood seven times. https://pjammcycling.com/climb/148.L...nwood%20Canyon And not slowly. His best time put him in 15th place on Strava, with first place being held by Sepp Kuss followed by a bunch of domestic and second-string Euro pros. But I mean really, riding the same climb over and over to rack up elevation? I'd rather be weeding my lawn. SLC is an interesting place because all the pretty riding is in the Wasatch, so you get leisure riders doing giant climbs. The easy climbs like Emigration Canyon are an ant-trail of cyclists on the weekends and during the epidemic. Coming from sea level, I'm always hypoxic riding in Salt Lake, so I have many fond memories of chasing my son up climbs. I think. And orange spots before my eyes -- and prickly cold arms on a hot day. -- Jay Beattie. |
#60
|
|||
|
|||
How flat are The Netherlands?
On 5/23/2020 12:04 PM, jbeattie wrote:
IMO, just getting elevation is neurotic. My son lives in SLC (and was on the Tour of Utah media crew the year after that crash on Guardsman) and has a friend who did 32,000 feet of climbing (divide by three) on a neighborhood street -- over and over just to get his Everest and a bit more. Last weekend,the same guy did Little Cottonwood seven times. https://pjammcycling.com/climb/148.L...nwood%20Canyon And not slowly. His best time put him in 15th place on Strava, with first place being held by Sepp Kuss followed by a bunch of domestic and second-string Euro pros. But I mean really, riding the same climb over and over to rack up elevation? I'd rather be weeding my lawn. I've never been a fan of climbing. I used to be fairly good at it - or at least, that's what others told me - but I actually wrote an article in an old issue of _Bicycling_ magazine about using USGS maps to avoid the hills. I have (younger) good friends who frequently do "hill repeats" rides using some nearby valleys. Climb, descend, climb, descend, repeat until you drop. I've never been on one of those rides. It does seem masochistic - much like doing a ride longer than 100 miles - but I guess the benefit is gaining the strength and confidence to be able to ride anywhere at all. A couple of those friends are planning to do yet another tour of the entire Skyline Drive, assuming the virus situation permits it. I've done only a small part of that route, and I admit to being jealous. -- - Frank Krygowski |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Liability in the Netherlands | Frank Krygowski[_2_] | Techniques | 14 | November 20th 13 05:49 AM |
Obesity in the Netherlands | Greens | Techniques | 56 | October 15th 07 12:20 AM |
LIVEDRUNK goes to the Netherlands | Ryan Cousineau | Racing | 9 | July 31st 07 08:30 AM |
Flat Resistant or Flat Proof Tires | Jeff Grippe | Recumbent Biking | 9 | February 3rd 07 05:35 AM |
Training in The Netherlands | Mark | UK | 5 | July 5th 05 11:47 PM |