|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#171
|
|||
|
|||
The case for physically separated bike lanes
"Tom Keats" wrote [snip] So many people look at the Dutch fietspaden and think they're perfect for everywhere. I opine those were largely implemented during post-war reconstruction. Rather than being slapped down as Urban Design afterthoughts, I think the Dutch took advantage of an opportunity to make their cycling facilities more integral features of their overall traffic system, and it works for them, along with their flat terrain. North American cities are not ready for fietspaden, and if they tried to implement them, the results would be half-hearted, incomplete and self-nullifying. Probably even dangerous. [snip] I think that Dutch bike facility building began about 1930 as part of the intercity road building that began as cars became common. I think that the first cycle tracks were built as a demonstration project by the All Dutch Cyclists Union. That wasn't (and isn't) quite such a cycling oriented organization as it sounds. It is more commonly known by the second name it adopted - the Royal Dutch Touring Club - when it decided to admit motorists in the early 1900s It's rather is if the USA's League of American Wheelmen/Bicyclists had decided to admit motorists, and mutated into the AAA. I think that there wasn't so much war damage in the Netherlands as some other places, owing to the Germans having overrun the Netherlands so quickly. I think, though, that downtown Rotterdam was blitzed, and had to be totally rebuilt in modern style, with a new street pattern, after the war. I haven't seen it, but I have never ever heard of downtown Rotterdam quoted as an example of how to build bike facilities. I think the roadbuilding program continued when economic recovery picked up after the war, in the late 1940s. This might well have been with the help of the Marshall Plan, so US money might have been behind some of the Netherlands' bike network I don't think there was anything like the US drift to the suburbs in that period. There would have been some "new town" building, though, especially associated with such projects as draining the Zuyder Zee. During that period the Swedish and the English were among the world's leaders in town planning, and the Dutch may well have observed Britain's Stevenage as an example of how to build bike oriented towns. Most towns stayed the way they always had been, without bike facilities When I was growing up in Europe in the 1940s it was generally believed that the Netherlands, and Denmark, had lots of bikes because they were flat, and compact, and that they had lots of cycle tracks because they had lots of bikes I think that after WWII the world, including the Netherlands, home of Shell Oil, regarded mass motorisation as the wave of the future. The first step in this was the moped, and the controversy began, was the moped a sort of bicycle, or was it a sort of motorcycle. In 1952 the Dutch voted to define it as a bicycle, and for the next twenty years Dutch cycle tracks became, de facto, moped tracks. That's why they tend to have sight lines suitable for vehicles going quite fast, but surfaces suitable only for vehicles with sprung suspensions In 1973 the first oil crisis hit, and the Arabs cut off the flow to the Netherlands and Shell. As a fuel conservation measure, driving a car on Sundays became illegal. The Netherlands, and the world, assumed there would be an oil shortage for the foreseeable future, and the foreseeable future did last for at least five years. The Dutch assumed that the fuel shortage would cause a mass switch to more fuel efficient vehicles, i.e. mopeds. Foreseeing an increase in moped accidents to correspond with the increase in mopeds they passed a compulsory helmet law (for mopeds, not bikes) Moped riding and moped buying immediately collapsed, and bike riding began to increase for the first time in years. Meanwhile bike riding had begun to revive in the USA. The low point was probably symbolized when the Verrezano Narrows Bridge was built without sidewalk or cycle track, and the revival began when Dr Paul Dudley White advised President Eisenhower to take up cycling after his heart attack. Davis, California, became overrun with bikes when the Agricultural School of the University of California was expanded into a full scale university in the early 1960s. The citizens of Davis were rather horrified to fined their streets cluttered up with bikes, and wanted to ban them. Eco-warrior types were beginning to campaign that it was the cars that should be banned instead. This became an issue in the town elections of 1966, and the result was compromise: apartheid (Suitably, the Dutch for separation). Special ghettos in the gutter were marked out for bikes, and thus was the bike lane invented Jeremy Parker |
Ads |
#172
|
|||
|
|||
The case for physically separated bike lanes
"Tom Keats" wrote in message news In article , "Bill Sornson" writes: Good lord, no wonder you people (not an Imus ref.) hate bike lanes. Those things are atrocities. That's what's meant by "physically separated" bike lanes, as per the subject line. [snip] Of course, there is no such thing as a "physically separated bike lane" That's just a euphemism for the facility that dare not speak its name, the cycle track. "Cycle track" has become an obscenity, not to be spoken in polite society. The problems with cycle tracks have been known for some time. Half a century ago, here in Britain, one for Britain's greatest town planners and traffic engineers, Professor Sir Colin Buchanan,. wrote, in his book "Mixed Blessing, The Motor in Britain" "The meagre efforts to separate cyclists from motor traffic have failed, tracks are inadequate, the problem of treating them at junctions and intersections is completely unsolved, and the attitude of cyclists themselves to these admittedly unsatisfactory tracks has not been as helpful as it might have been." Jeremy Parker |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
What airline bike case to buy? (Trico Iron Case or XPORT Cargo Case?) | Robert Hayden | General | 2 | July 14th 06 04:26 PM |
Getting Bike Lanes - LONG was Bracelets for Bike Lanes? | The Wogster | General | 0 | April 22nd 05 07:10 PM |
Getting Bike Lanes - LONG was Bracelets for Bike Lanes? | The Wogster | Social Issues | 0 | April 21st 05 06:16 PM |
Getting Bike Lanes - LONG was Bracelets for Bike Lanes? | Tom Keats | General | 0 | April 21st 05 05:29 AM |
Getting Bike Lanes - LONG was Bracelets for Bike Lanes? | Tom Keats | Social Issues | 0 | April 21st 05 05:29 AM |