|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
As I marveled at the silky smooth ride my suspension seatpost was
giving me, I started wondering ... what other benefits or liabilities did it have on my bike. The spring was absorbing the shock to my body. Was it absorbing energy and relieving stress else where? Was it lessening the stress on my frame and wheels by absorbing some of the weight of my body slamming into the seat as I encountered bumps in the road? Or was it causing more stress on the wheels since I was able to take those bumps at a higher rate of speed due to the suspension seatpost? I was just curious... |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
Rocketman58 wrote:
As I marveled at the silky smooth ride my suspension seatpost was giving me, I started wondering ... what other benefits or liabilities did it have on my bike. The spring was absorbing the shock to my body. Was it absorbing energy and relieving stress else where? Was it lessening the stress on my frame and wheels by absorbing some of the weight of my body slamming into the seat as I encountered bumps in the road? Or was it causing more stress on the wheels since I was able to take those bumps at a higher rate of speed due to the suspension seatpost? I was just curious... Dear Rocket Any suspension reduces the shock of impact for everything--that's wh they're called shock absorbers and let us go faster over bumps As an analogy, a boxing glove protects both the fist and the skull With a suspension post, the bicycle can be shoved upward against th enormous (m)ass resting on the seat and will encounter less resistanc than normal. This is felt by the bicycle below the post as a smoother less bumpy ride, just as the (m)ass above the seat post feels delightfully improved smoothness The shock absorber gets crushed from both top and bottom, absorbs th shock, and suffers in silence. It converts the energy of compression t heat and to re-expansion, but spreads the work out over a longer period reducing the shock Hitting a bump, the bike rises against the cushion of the suspension compressing it, and then the suspension expands, belatedly shoving yo upward more slowly and gently than a solid post. The spring action soak up the jolt and slows it down, so both rider and bicycle benefit Put a suspension device between the bicycle and the road (a pneumati tire) and the same thing occurs--the jolts are softened Or so I hear. I once had to finish a trials event with one rear shoc unit bent at 90 degrees and never again said anything unkind about thos rear shocks--darned useful devices Carl Foge - |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
Any suspension reduces the shock of impact for everything--that's why
they're called shock absorbers and let us go faster over bumps. As an analogy, a boxing glove protects both the fist and the skull. With a suspension post, the bicycle can be shoved upward against the enormous (m)ass resting on the seat and will encounter less resistance than normal. This is felt by the bicycle below the post as a smoother, less bumpy ride, just as the (m)ass above the seat post feels a delightfully improved smoothness. The shock absorber gets crushed from both top and bottom, absorbs the shock, and suffers in silence. It converts the energy of compression to heat and to re-expansion, but spreads the work out over a longer period, reducing the shock. Hitting a bump, the bike rises against the cushion of the suspension, compressing it, and then the suspension expands, belatedly shoving you upward more slowly and gently than a solid post. The spring action soaks up the jolt and slows it down, so both rider and bicycle benefit. Put a suspension device between the bicycle and the road (a pneumatic tire) and the same thing occurs--the jolts are softened. Or so I hear. I once had to finish a trials event with one rear shock unit bent at 90 degrees and never again said anything unkind about those rear shocks--darned useful devices. Carl Fogel Cool. Rocketman58 |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
"rocketman58" wrote in message
om... As I marveled at the silky smooth ride my suspension seatpost was giving me, I started wondering ... what other benefits or liabilities did it have on my bike. The spring was absorbing the shock to my body. Was it absorbing energy and relieving stress else where? Was it lessening the stress on my frame and wheels by absorbing some of the weight of my body slamming into the seat as I encountered bumps in the road? Yes. But you can do the same thing more effectively by not riding like a sack of potatoes. Or was it causing more stress on the wheels since I was able to take those bumps at a higher rate of speed due to the suspension seatpost? No. Suspension seats have been around since the bicycle has, most of them use springs. The other low-tech solution is pneumatic tires, most of us use them. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
.....Yes. But you can do the same thing more effectively by not riding
like a sack of potatoes.... Hmm, I don't ever remember riding like a sack of pototoes. After 25 year of hard core ridding, I have pretty good riding skills. But, at 46 years old, I'm not in the same shape as I used to be. In addition, I have a few injuries from my MTB racing days. I pretty much stay seated while riding now, and my bars are higher than seat due to an old wrist injury. Thus the practical need for the suspension post. .....Suspension seats have been around since the bicycle has, most of them use springs... modern suspension seats typically use elastomers (such as mine does). .....The other low-tech solution is pneumatic tires, most of us use them.... I guess that's why I running 26c wide tires on my road bike. Back in the old days of MTB racing, letting some air out of our "pneumatic tires" was the only form of suspension we had, other than relaxed geometry frames. I never found Brooks type leather seats with springs too practial for technical off road riding. Rocketman58 |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
RE/
Yes. But you can do the same thing more effectively by not riding like a sack of potatoes. Agreed, but it sure is nice to have that sus under you when the occasinal bump sneaks up and you take inadvertantly it sitting. -- PeteCresswell |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
"rocketman58" wrote in message
om... ....Yes. But you can do the same thing more effectively by not riding like a sack of potatoes.... Hmm, I don't ever remember riding like a sack of pototoes. After 25 year of hard core ridding, I have pretty good riding skills. But, at 46 years old, I'm not in the same shape as I used to be. Wow, that *is* old, maybe you should switch to golf. In addition, I have a few injuries from my MTB racing days. I pretty much stay seated while riding now, and my bars are higher than seat due to an old wrist injury. Thus the practical need for the suspension post. My wife rides that way, so do many people (bars higher than seat), it doesn't require suspension. ....Suspension seats have been around since the bicycle has, most of them use springs... modern suspension seats typically use elastomers (such as mine does). Yeah, which makes them suck in cold weather. Most suspension seatposts have so much stiction that they work worse than sprung saddles. The parallelogram ones work much better. The only difference between elastomers and springs is that the elastomers are supposed to provide some damping, in reality, they don't provide very much. ....The other low-tech solution is pneumatic tires, most of us use them.... I guess that's why I running 26c wide tires on my road bike. I don't know what "26c" means. Back in the old days of MTB racing, letting some air out of our "pneumatic tires" was the only form of suspension we had, other than relaxed geometry frames. You must have ridden pretty mellow courses not to pinch flat. I think the suspension effect of "relaxed geometry" frames must have been imaginary. I never found Brooks type leather seats with springs too practial for technical off road riding. A whole lot of people find sprung saddles practical for off-road riding, especially back when on-road riding was the equivalent of off-roading today. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
Suspension is the wave of the future, not just for confort but for
elite road athletes. Those who claim that manliness decrees you must stand up and use your legs as shock absorbers ignore the constant tension/waste of energy needed to keep legs tensed to use them as shocks in all situations; as well as those painful situations where you just don't see a potholein time, don't stand up, and thus take a nasty shock to the spine.. I just did the Copperopolis road race today, total crap roads, and my back would be wrecked w/o my suspension seatpost. But it's not just because I'm a master's lard-muffinFL: An 18 year old I met who rode at the national level is thinking of getting one too. He said his back was so messed up after nationals he couldn't walk. The spine is not engineered to take constant direct hits like a racing bike gives through the pelvis. Evolution designed the legs and feet to proide this protection. But this is at cross purposes with using them to pedal. Your back tenses up in response to the continued microtraumas. I believe chronic tensing of the muscles wastes energy, my guess is the realization of this will result in professional cyclists starting to use shock posts in about 2-4 years as research emerges. It will take a leader beating the others like LeMond beat Fignon with aero bars to remove the sissy stigma. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
RE/
I believe chronic tensing of the muscles wastes energy, Speaking as somebody at the low end of the strength-endurance curve, I perceive a huge difference between riding my hard-tail and my FS - same tires, same terrain, same wasted body. Traction is not a factor here because I don't normally put out enough horsepower for the FS advantage to kick in traction/control-wise. It's just the diff between having to use the legs to protect the butt/back and not having to. I still like the FS for the variety, for the responsiveness, and because it forces me to make my legs take a more active role in shock absorbtion...but the calories required to cover the same distance is definately higher without suspension - even when only riding uneven pavement or rough gravel. My guess is that the same holds for sus post vs rigid. -- PeteCresswell |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Other Suspension seatpost benefits?
|
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Has anyone ever tried the NitroPro Suspension Seatpost? | GS | General | 4 | June 8th 05 01:57 PM |
How Would Suspension Help? | Elisa Francesca Roselli | General | 23 | July 28th 04 04:51 AM |
Anybody try Suntour parallalogram suspension seatpost? | plowtechie | Mountain Biking | 1 | May 27th 04 07:12 PM |
Does the world have room for another full suspension design? | Simon Brooke | Techniques | 31 | January 5th 04 04:21 PM |
Linking forward and rear suspension | Simon Brooke | Techniques | 18 | November 27th 03 03:22 AM |